To watch or not to watch? That is the question TVGuide.com examines as Idol enters the twilight of its tween years:





Read More >





Other Links From TVGuide.com
American IdolKelly ClarksonMariah CareyCarrie UnderwoodKeith UrbanJennifer HudsonKatharine McPheeAmerica's Got TalentNigel LythgoeDreamgirlsThe X FactorNicki MinajScotty McCreeryThe VoiceSmash